36 ISE Magazine | www.iise.org/ISEmagazine
AI engineering solutions from the garden
How Turing’s explorations of sunflowers helped inspire artificial intelligence
By Joseph Byrum
Sometimes inspiration comes from the unlikeli-
est of places. For Alan Turing, the code-breaking
hero of World War II, the patterns he found in
nature influenced his approach to solving the
problems of computing and artificial intelligence.
It all started in his garden.
Last July, the Bank of England announced the renowned
computer scientist would appear on the 50-pound bank
note opposite the queen, an honor once reserved for 17th
and 18th century pioneers like steam engine creator James
Watt. The first note will circulate toward the end of 2021.
The idea behind the currency change is to showcase
Turing’s work developing the automatic computing engine
that helped break Axis ciphers in the 1940s. The Bank of
England’s selection committee noted Turing himself said
the primitive computing device was “only a foretaste of
what is to come, and only the shadow of what is going to
be.”
Those achievements were on display in the Oscar-win-
ning film The Imitation Game, but don’t expect Benedict
Cumberbatch to reprise his role in a sequel (or more ac-
curately, prequel) in which Turing might be found in his
garden counting the spirals on the face of sunflowers.
But that’s the sort of thing Turing spent time doing. He
looked at the face of the sunflower and wanted to learn why
it looked the way it did. While the distribution of seeds on
the flower’s face appeared to be random, his counts re-
vealed a complicated pattern. Specifically, the sunflower
tended to have 89 spirals of densely packed seeds in one
direction and 55 in the other. Both 55 and 89 are num-
bers in the Fibonacci sequence, which describes a series in
which each figure is the sum of the two that came before it.
Thus, 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, 34, 55, 89, 144 and so on are
Fibonacci numbers. Numbers in this sequence are related
to the next number in a ratio that approaches closer to the
golden mean, 1.618, as the value of the number increases.
Turing was so fascinated by the discovery that he set out
to find a physical explanation for his mathematical obser-
vation. He entered the discipline of quantitative biology,
which became a lifelong passion. His final published work,
“The Chemical Basis of Morphogenesis (1952),” still in-
spires researchers today.
In the paper, Turing described how chemicals react and
diffuse with one another to create seemingly random-
looking structures, like spots on a leopard or stripes on
a zebra, that actually follow a discernible mathematical
S
April 2020 | ISE Magazine 37
pattern. Biologists and engineers in China recently applied
this understanding of the reaction-diffusion process to create
a highly effective water filter that promises to have related
uses in other fields such as medicine.
The link between biology and AI
There was nothing random about Turing’s interests in biol-
ogy, cryptology, artificial intelligence (AI) and computing.
In each, Turing sought to draw out a discernible, mathemati-
cal pattern to create a greater understanding.
The “imitation game,” for instance, was created as a test
to determine whether a computer at some point in the future
might have the ability to communicate with several humans
in such a convincing fashion that the participants wouldn’t
know they were talking to a machine. To beat the Turing
Test, a machine would “learn” the patterns of humans and
replicate them. The machine would gather knowledge in the
same way a child does.
He thought it would take 50 years to develop machines
powerful enough to do this and win the game, which was
not a bad estimate considering how much progress has been
made recently.
He saw the computing machines of his time not as crude,
unwieldy and extremely limited devices. Turing was look-
ing at the potential he thought would not be realized until
the next century. Even if the future machines didn’t “think”
the way we do, he reasoned, the result might nonetheless be
indistinguishable from actual thought. A machine, despite
being constrained by mathematics and logic, might be able to
mimic the apparent randomness of human creativity.
As Turing noted, “the appreciation of something as sur-
prising requires as much of a ‘creative mental act’ whether
the surprising event originates from a man, a book, a ma-
chine or anything else.”
Applying Turing’s method
to the world of finance
Turing never wrote a paper on finance, but he did attempt
to apply his genius to maintain his personal wealth. With the
uncertainty of war in 1940, he decided the smartest move
was to trade his cash for silver ingots. He proceeded to bury
them around Bletchley Park as a means of evading the twin
threats of foreign invasion and the tax man.
Modern financial analysts have discovered more impres-
sive mathematical techniques to maximize return than bury-
ing bullion in the backyard. Traders have found, for instance,
that the same Fibonacci sequence that determines a sunflow-
er’s look also plays some kind of role in stock prices. They use
a set of numbers in the Fibonacci sequence (23.6, 38.2, 50,
61.8, 78.6 and 100 most commonly) as value levels to con-
sider when trying to forecast the direction of a stock price.
If a stock is on the rise, an analyst will pay attention as it
hits each threshold – 23.6 percent, 38.2 percent, and so on.
At the upper thresholds like 76.4 and 100, the analyst espe-
cially prepares for the stock to reverse course and start losing
value. On the downswing, the same intervals become the
“floor” for the stock’s value. Once it hits one of those lower
intervals, traders believe the stock tends not to go any lower.
Why do these intervals matter? Most believe it is a con-
sequence of market psychology. The Fibonacci ratios and
golden mean in sunflowers reflect the order and balance of
nature. When traders see a commodity rise by, say 100%,
they might feel the stock value is disproportionately high –
similarly to how things in nature don’t feel right when they
are out of proportion.
None of this is necessarily a conscious choice. It’s just a
possible explanation underlying a system commonly used in
finance and trading algorithms.
Fibonacci ratios show up in the unlikeliest of places, and
in so doing, they can serve as an unlikely inspiration. They
are, like Turing’s sunflowers, a reminder that order may be
found in systems that appear to be inherently disordered – an
important lesson for all systems engineers.
Joseph Byrum is the chief data scientist at Principal and an IISE
member. He was previously senior R&D and strategic marketing
executive in life sciences-global product development, innovation and
delivery at Syngenta. In that role, he was chief architect of initiatives
that won Syngenta the 2016 ANA Genius Award in Marketing
Analytics and 2015 Franz Edelman prize for contributions in op-
erations research and the management sciences. His bachelor’s degree
in crop and soil science and his master’s degree in genetics are from
Michigan State University. He earned a master’s degree in business
administration from the University of Michigan Stephen M. Ross
School of Business. His Ph.D. in quantitative genetics is from Iowa
State University.
Computer scientist Alan Turing will appear on the Bank of
England’s 50-pound bank note opposite the queen in 2021. He is
honored for his work to break Axis codes during World War II.
Photo courtesy of Joseph Byrum